Robot radio comes closer, with RadioGPT - but is it any good?
A press release from Futuri Media promised a thing called RadioGPT™. It read like the sort of thing that I should be implacably against.
“The World’s First AI-Driven Localized Radio Content”, RadioGPT is a system that a) watches social media for trending topics in your local area; b) writes a script apparently using GPT-3 technology; c) uses AI voices to make radio with them. It has the horrible title of “live, local, and powered by AI”.
I shared the press release on social media. People responded with the usual “this sounds like an awful idea. AI voices aren’t there yet. Nobody will use this. This is the worst idea”. And I hoped that was true.
But then, I discovered that there was a live stream demo of this dreadful service that anyone can listen to. So, I took a listen (while on a train in Sydney), looking forward to being really rather rude about this horrible idea.
Irritatingly, though: it’s rather good.
Now, there are some smoke and mirrors being deployed here by Futuri for the test stream. It isn’t live: it’s a loop. The voices may be AI, but either they’re the best AI voices out there, or someone’s tuned their delivery rather suspiciously well. I know that TopicPulse does use some human moderation, too. The stream cleverly just says every voice is AI: this isn’t a 100% AI-produced service.
There are some clever tricks, too. The songs in the demo stream are all 90-second edits (good for a demo). The local news is for “Springfield” - someone’s a fan of the Simpsons at Futuri towers.
The little bits of news, scripted to have a little joke at the end of them, work well. The station sounds tight. It’s undoubtedly more “live and local” than ten great songs in a row can be.
The little factoids about the bands that play are interesting and decent, too. The only concern I’d have is that they’d need to be rotated quite sparingly to have the desired effect.
Sure, some phrases don’t sound quite right if you listen really carefully. But then, some phrases spoken by human beings don’t sound quite right either. (“This podcast is supported by advertising outside the UK”, which international audiences hear in front of most BBC podcasts, has the emphasis in the wrong place, skipping past the word ‘advertising’ and seemingly stressing the word ‘side’).
But, for an overnight shift, or a weekend service, or even to replace the non-stop music sweeps during the day, this is actually quite a passable listen, much though it pains me to say so. It’s worth a listen.
If you like AI-powered radio DJs, you’re going to get quite a few of them in the next six months, I suspect.
Spotify launched its own - which a) doesn’t sound like AI at all (and I suspect it’s been entirely faked for the press release’s video), and b) seems to contain nothing of any use, unlike RadioGPT. It’s a discombobulated voice telling you that “you listened to quite a lot of songs from the 1970s recently so here is another one” or “here’s a new release from a music type you love” without actually telling you the new release. Of all of the finesse of RadioGPT, this comes very lacking.
Dan Taylor-Watt has published rather an excellent animation of the top 20 radio stations in the UK over the past decade. It highlights how static everything is, really. Worth a look.
Global’s Radio X launched its first brand extension in mid February. Nik Goodman has taken a look at how it works musically.
Ken Bruce, who was due to leave BBC Radio 2 at the end of April, has been quietly asked to finish up this week. Dan Cocker is bored of reading the annoying social posts about how badly Bruce has been treated. Meanwhile, Matt Deegan writes about why most DJs don’t even get a “last week” on-air, which I think understandable if rude to listeners and the presenter themselves.
- I was given a “last week” on-air when I was a full-time radio presenter, by the excellent Steve Martin (no, not that one). It probably helped that I was going to move to a staff job in the same company, at a different radio station, though. I didn’t get the chance to say goodbye after five years of Hallam FM shifts, though, to my regret; but my last words on the station - “I’ll see you next week, hopefully” - showed that it probably didn’t come as much of a surprise.
Everyone’s favourite radio stunt inventor, Paige Nienaber (crazy name, crazy guy), has been sharing some fun hunt the balloon to get some concert tickets tweets.
Some visual radio from the good folk at Global - and I’m fascinated at quite where Nick Ferrari’s microphone is here.
I’m called a “radio expert” in this piece by the Telegraph. I’ll take that. This is the not-entirely-unexpected news that talkSPORT, the UK’s remaining national commercial AM broadcaster, is wanting to turn some of its AM transmitters off. It was sharing infrastructure with Absolute Radio, who came off earlier this year. talkSPORT is, of course, not a music station - and arguably stands to temporarily benefit from Absolute’s retreat.
Want to supercharge your radio show? Here’s a £1 week-long trial of Show Prep - from a world class radio consultant and the best show-prep writer in the UK. Great for UK stations, or for English-language stations everywhere, too. (ad)
Supporters
Thank you, Ross Winters, for the five coffees. I’m looking forward to seeing him in Toronto in June for Radiodays North America.
Thank you also to Dominic, who agreed wholeheartedly with my grumble about the BBC’s bullying of its listeners to download the BBC Sounds app if they want to keep listening. He agreed so much, three more coffees are on the way.
And thank you to Lisa Kerr, who writes: “I love that you keep me in touch with my old world”. She came to Australia recently, Facebook tells me, but didn’t pop in for a coffee. (Good job, too, my drip filter only makes one cup).
Thank you, too, to Richard Hilton, James Masterton, and Brun Audio Consulting for your ongoing support of this newsletter. I’m very grateful to you.
If you’d like to support my work in any way, you can BuyMeACoffee - become a member to give regularly or just give a one-off coffee, or five. Here’s where to do that.
I’m at the IAB Audio Summit in Sydney tomorrow; at Podcast Movement Evolutions in Las Vegas Mar 6-11; Radiodays Europe in Prague Mar 25-30; the NAB Show in mid-April; the New Zealand Podcast Summit in mid May; the Podcast Show 2023 in London at the end of May; and Radiodays North America in early June. Here are my contact details if you’re there, too.
I’m on Mastodon as @james@bne.social (or just search for my regular james@crid.land email address).
My professional website has more detail about who I am, and what I do, and whether I can help you further.