James Cridland's blog

A radio futurologist writing about what happens when radio and new platforms collide

« | Blog index | »

Long term review: Apple TV and Boxee

Posted on Tuesday, May 26th, 2009 at 10:35pm. #

Around four months ago, I gave myself a treat: an Apple TV.

Here’s what I wanted: a way to watch BBC iPlayer in fullscreen on my telly. I have a Mac Mini which runs my iTunes installation; that’s permanently plugged into the telly, but it’s super under-powered, and Flash (on a Power PC-powered Mac Mini) in full-screen gives me about two frames a second. So I seriously looked at upgrading my Mac Mini – then read up on the rather cheaper Apple TV.

Turns out that Apple TV runs Boxee pretty well. In fact, very well. It’s not hard to do, either.

And, as I discovered during CES in January, Boxee comes with BBC iPlayer baked into it. In fact, the user interface looks very similar to the BBC iPlayer bigscreen interface. The Boxee implementation is not an official BBC iPlayer release, so expect it to break as iPlayer does updates to their website (and it does break, though not seemingly for too long).

Adding Boxee to my Apple TV was quick and simple: you need to fiddle with some software on a USB key, stick that USB key into your Apple TV, reboot it, stand on one leg while holding your nose and humming a Beatles track, and watch while you get Boxee on your Apple TV. Then… just play.

I’ve now got access to a -ton- of great TV programming, including the BBC iPlayer, clips from CBS, full shows from Comedy Channel, output from CNet, Current TV, Joost, and a ton more stuff. Radio is also well catered for, with Last FM support, as well as RadioTime (a radio guide) and direct listings for BBC podcasts as well. (That’s also unofficial, a lawyer might remind me to say).

It works beautifully with my nearly 8-meg internet connection; and the picture quality from BBC iPlayer is fullscreen and almost as good as Freeview (I’ve no idea what bitrate they actually use since I can’t right-click on the player window). Further, programmes from Revision3 (DiggNation, Systm, etc) appear to be in HD, which is nice. CNET is a little disappointing, being in fairly blurry low-res; and Hulu appears tantalisingly on the menu but is, so far, unusable.

Better still, I discover that my Logitech 555 universal remote also talks to my Apple TV, which is neat.

I now do all my BBC iPlayer viewing on this thing; and watch a surprising amount of other programming through it. I duck out of Boxee mode occasionally to download the latest version of the software – and go straight back into Boxee mode afterwards.

Boxee isn’t the world’s best user interface – I’m forever activating bits I didn’t mean to – and try as I might, I can’t get it to talk to my Mac Mini to play any music from it. Mind, I don’t particularly care. It’s purely an internet media device, and it does that job pretty well.

Watch a BBC iPlayer programme on it and it’s almost impossible to realise that it’s not off the Sky+ box. Which, given my Sky dish is currently covered by a large tree, is possibly a good thing: I wonder how long I’ll last with Freeview and the BBC iPlayer?

Photo: John Ousby. Used under licence. Thanks, John, and enjoy Texas.

5 comments

DonT
commenting at May 27th, 2009 at 8:00am

Ah damn – bit late now – but you could have got a nice HP Pavillion Slimline whistper quiet PC with Vista which comes with Windows Media Centre, Freeview tuner, remote, PVR blah blah all built in.
Plus – Tuner Free – lets you plug into all stations including HULU. http://www.milliesoft.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=9:iplayer-mce&catid=1:software&Itemid=11

James Cridland
commenting at May 27th, 2009 at 10:14am

Still wouldn’t get Hulu for me… it’s denied to “rest of the worlders” like me.

Michael Tyas
commenting at May 27th, 2009 at 5:35pm

There’s a couple of bits of free software that can disguise your ip address and fool Hulu into thinking you’re in the US so it works. Just google hiding your ip.

Bruce Mitchell
commenting at May 27th, 2009 at 10:03pm

Installed Boxee on my ATV at weekend and spent tonight glued to iPlayer on my plasma, surround sound etc. I may never leave the house again…

Chris Stevens
commenting at May 28th, 2009 at 3:38am

I’ll swap you Hulu for the iPlayer…

Leave a comment

Here's my commenting policy