James Cridland's blog

A radio futurologist writing about what happens when radio and new platforms collide

« | Blog index | »

Compare my radio blows radio’s music secrets open

Posted on Friday, October 16th, 2009 at 6:30pm. #

Simples!

Another magical thing from One Golden Square Labs has just surfaced: Compare my radio.

It’s yet another comparison site. But this time, it’s not for car insurance, or, indeed, for small mammals from the mongoose family. It’s for music radio.

Last.fm tells me that I am a fan of The Beatles, The Eels, and the Divine Comedy. Compare My Radio tells me that The Beatles are most played on Absolute Classic Rock; that NME Radio has a particular penchant for The Eels; and that the Divine Comedy’s natural home is BBC 6 Music. I would never have thought of listening to NME Radio, it should be said, for the type of music I’m into. Good work, CompareMyRadio.

What’s more interesting is the website’s comparison of some of the radio stations. No surprise that Heart in London, and Heart in the East Midlands, share 96% of their playlist. More interesting that Absolute Radio and Rock Radio share 66% of theirs; and I find it, as a non-music programmer, quite interesting that XFM and NME Radio in London are poles apart: sharing only 27% of their playlists. And it’s all done with a rather lovely user interface – including the delightfulness of sparklines. Yay for sparklines! ;)

This is a brave move by Absolute Radio, the company behind this new website. It’s carefully not branded by Absolute; indeed, as my figures show, it’s not recommending the main Absolute Radio service to me at all. Doubtless it’ll ruffle feathers – while it’s using open data, I’ll bet some stations won’t be particularly pleased about their playlists being dissected in this way (though they’d be mad to complain, it should be said).

It would, of course, be better if the service was able to recommend me a radio station by looking at my last.fm profile or my iTunes library data, rather than individual artists. And, given that many programmes on BBC Radio run very different music policies, it might be nice to split this data to programme level (though that’s made rather more difficult to do because radio stations have to date been pretty poor at sharing programme data in an open way).

Notwithstanding that, this is a really interesting piece of work into the output of the UK’s major radio stations – stations that between them are listened-to by over 50% of the population. One Golden Square Labs should, once more, be congratulated.

Of course, I’m reminded of the work that the BBC did in this area over a year ago (during the ‘Mashed!’ hack weekend). Testing the recommendation service, I punched in my last.fm profile, and the information that came back was that I might rather enjoy the Russell Brand show on BBC Radio 2. If only I could have enjoyed the purile rubbish that came between the songs…

(Full disclosure: most of Golden Square Labs worked for me at one stage, and are friends of mine; and I saw Compare My Radio before general release, and told them to put a ‘listen to’ button in there. They have. Hurray.)

5 comments

John Martin
commenting at October 16th, 2009 at 8:12pm

Thanks James…

All your points about improvements are valid… we’re working towards a version 1.1 of Compare My Radio that should include these exact things. At the moment the site is great for getting an aggregate view of the data and in the future we’re looking to deliver a even better personalised experience for users.

Follow http://twitter.com/OGSLabs for updates.

Kev
commenting at October 16th, 2009 at 9:25pm

Neat site that one – my two most listened to stations are Smooth (East Midlands) and XFM – comparing the London version of those shows that:

XFM London played 653 unique tracks
Smooth Radio London played 2,137 unique tracks
XFM London and Smooth Radio London have 4% of their playlist which is the same

I thought the Smooth Radio played more music than XFM, but just quite how many more tracks is rather surprising!

And the artist recommendations suggest that Absoulte Xtreme (which my WiFi radio insists on calling Virgin Xtreme even though I wiped the preset) is worth giving another shot (shame it’s not on DAB to make that possible more of the time).

The BBC 6 Music / XFM comparison http://www.comparemyradio.com/compare/BBC_6_Music/XFM_London shows how little music XFM actually play – nearly all of XFM’s music is played by 6Music, but only 19% of the combined tracks shared are played by both!

Mark Farrington
commenting at October 19th, 2009 at 2:28pm

The other thing that would be nice would be a submission interface for smaller stations, or an API so people could compare their own data to it.

There’s code along these lines behind the Music Section of the SRA website (although granted it’s nowhere near finished) which is aimed at recommending a student station to visitors based on their tastes, or possibly even individual shows (although the scheduling stuff isn’t that clever yet).

Mmmmm Data….

Senate Judiciary approves Performance Rights Act- Online Radio Station for Independent Artist
commenting at October 26th, 2009 at 7:17pm

[...] is far greater. Imagine, as James Cridland suggests in his commentary of the CompareMyRadio (here), if the site could link with your Last.fm or iTunes data. And then imagine what Absolute Radio [...]

Michael Saunders
commenting at December 16th, 2009 at 4:04pm

Not tried it myself, but there is a tool for recommending which BBC Radio shows you should listen to, based on your Last.fm profile – http://music-recommendations.metade.org/

Leave a comment

Here's my commenting policy