James.Cridland.net

James Cridland's blog

Where radio and new platforms collide. With beer.

« 8 Random Facts About Me (tagging meme) | Blog index | The new BBC homepage - website credits »

iPlayer - on GNU/Linux

Posted on Wednesday, December 12th, 2007 at 9:51pm. #

iPlayer on Ubuntu

I like The Register - it’s an excellent resource which is enjoyable to read. Yesterday, it reported: (A BBC spokeswoman said) that the (iPlayer) streaming service, for those without Windows XP or Vista, will “hopefully” launch within the next two weeks.

Well, “launch within the next two weeks” craftily means anything - launch within the next 14 days… or launch within the next 24 hours. It actually meant the latter, since the new BBC iPlayer went live at around 5.00pm today. Above, you can see me using it on my Ubuntu box.

Contrary to the apparent quote, the streaming service is for all, whatever OS you’re using, as long as it’s got Flash support. You can just click and watch the best of the last seven days of BBC television (recent programmes only, not all are in Flash yet). And, using the nifty new ‘radio’ button, you can click and listen to the best of the last seven days’ of BBC Radio, too - the radio player has also had a nip & tuck. The download service still exists, for those of us on the combination of Windows XP and Internet Explorer (shudder). And, thank heavens, there’s no need to log in any more. Phew.

I know how much work the new streaming iPlayer has been for the various teams around the BBC and Red Bee who’ve made this work so well; and, as a former colleague of mine said to me this afternoon, “Blimey, I might actually use it now”, which really is high praise! Test it out with Have I Got News for You - it’s pretty good quality, I think.

To compare it with its competition - ITV.com’s “just click and watch” service requires MSIE to stream, as well as Windows Media Player with DRM - all the drawbacks of the original iPlayer, none of the download and take-away benefits. Channel 4 is download only, using a similar Kontiki client to the iPlayer that makes this Windows machine use 100% of its CPU, get hot and virtually stop responding: I’ve uninstalled it, but KService.exe is clearly still there. Hateful thing. I believe there’s a new client available today too on /iPlayer, but I can’t make my machine behave long enough to download it. Joost, for me, never plays without buffering - a shame, since there’s a ton of decent content on there. There’s some good content on iTunes for download (like channelflip.com) - and yes, of course, there’s BitTorrent, too. And I really must go and install Miro on the Mac under the telly - I’ve heard that’s rather splendid. Might do that now. Where’s the VNC?

9 comments

Chris Howell said at December 12th, 2007 at 11:52pm

I love the way the volume goes all the way to 11
and the face that it works perfectly on my iMac.
brilliant.

Joff said at December 13th, 2007 at 8:40am

That’s good news - I can watch Spooks in my statutory lunch break, yay.

I’ll still use the horrible Kontiki thing, though, since I like to watch things on my telly. The quality of the Flash-based content is quite a bit lower, for obvious reasons I suppose.

William T said at December 13th, 2007 at 1:25pm

Wow that’s fantastic… I second the ‘I might actually use it now’ comment. Just think of all the bad publicity that could have been avoided had the elegant streaming bit been built first and the fiddly downloads added afterwards…

Incidentally I like the little visual clues that are being added to the Radio Player these days (e.g. the “Why has this changed?” and, (I paraphrase) “Why is everything broken?” from the database problems a month or two back. Shows the BBC can be open about iterative development.)

As an aside, I suspect the beeb are perhaps the only organisation keeping Realplayer afloat nowadays - I had some dealings with them in the past and most of the people who were there seem to have jumped ship to Google etc. And, despite the fact that Realplayer was quite fun to develop for, I’m finding the Windows Media plugin decidedly quicker and more reliable to use. With the move to streaming, I wonder if Real will still exist as a company in a few years time?

Understanding » Blog Archive » BBC iPlayer is now DRM Free! said at December 13th, 2007 at 2:03pm

[...] yet work with Gnash at all, although I hope that will change shortly. The most excellent James Cridland has a screenshot of it running with the proprietary Adobe Flash player, making it all the more [...]

sine nomine said at December 13th, 2007 at 8:14pm

Do you need a television licence to watch?

Ted Swart said at December 14th, 2007 at 11:31pm

Wow! Looks as if sensible and relentless critique actually works sometimes. What a singular victory.

David Gerard said at December 15th, 2007 at 12:37pm

To get it working with Gnash, get a copy of the Flash source to the Gnash developers so they know exactly what they need to get working in Gnash to make it work. They may suggest you use function X instead of function Y or whatever, but it’ll be the best way to make it work on the full beardy free software stack.

Mark said at December 15th, 2007 at 2:55pm

I am (was) also using iPlayer on Ubuntu Linux. Unfortunately I did the upgrade to Flashplayer 9.0.115.0 in order to get fullscreen and now it just crashes Firefox when I click on play - interestingly the problem doesn’t occur with Youtube.

Not sure whether you picked up on an announcement a few weeks back that BBC, ITV and C4 are working together to provide a standard player for all their services. I assume this will be be based on the BBC version (i.e. Flash) and, once completed, I believe it will be one of the biggest changes to the way we look at TV in the UK. Imagine having a simple cheap set top box (similar to the one BT are using) using Linux based OS with the ability to watch and record terrestrial digital TV as well as being able to watch free and paid-for streamed “on-demand” programming from all 3 of the major UK programme providers via broadband. It wouldn’t be long before other content providers started to make their stuff available direct to customers same way and the current middlemen (Sky and Virgin Media) will fade into insignificance.

Stephen said at March 20th, 2008 at 4:33pm

Hi,
A friend of mine worked on the iPlayer and is responsible for the volume going to 11 - a knowing nod to spinal tap!

Leave a comment

This website's Gravatar enabled (that's the pictures on the right)