James.Cridland.net

James Cridland's blog

Where radio and new platforms collide. With beer.

« Has your radio station got a Marty? | Blog index | Discovery for radio stations »

Sky News vs BBC News 24

Posted on Monday, June 25th, 2007 at 9:16pm. #


Photo: Xerones @ Flickr, cc licenced

Watching the stories about the floods in Yorkshire, it’s been interesting to switch between Sky News and BBC News 24.

BBC News 24 is talking to journalists, rescue workers, firemen, policemen, etc. The questions from the studio are the standard “What’s the latest where you are?”.

Sky News - Anna Botting, who is live on-air - is talking directly to people who are trapped. People stuck upstairs, workmen who are ‘really quite cold now’ in their warehouses, people stuck in their cars. The journalist’s questions are sympathetic, interesting, warm.

Which do you think is the most interesting?

Clue: it’s not what the BBC is doing.

3 comments

John Handelaar said at June 25th, 2007 at 10:51pm

What Sky’s doing has value. But Ethel with her floating ironing board can’t tell anybody in the area whether it’s going to rain again soon, how long the standing water’s likely to be there, or how much longer the fire pumps are going to take draining her street.

Or in other words, they’re both doing it wrong.

Adam Bowie said at June 25th, 2007 at 11:21pm

Ah, but what’s most interesting is not necessarily the same as what’s most newsworthy. There may only be a relatively small number of people still “trapped” (and I really mean temporarily inconvenienced), yet tens of thousands more are suffering from flooded homes, have had to abandon their cars, rescue their livestock or whatever.

No, I wouldn’t want to have to spend the night on the top floor of the building I work in (ahem), but the story is more than just those relatively few people. That’s not to say that Sky hasn’t got a scoop in getting an interview, just that the wider picture is as important, if not more so, than human interest pieces.

(Not having seen the report, I take all this back if turns out that a torrential flood was about to wash away the person on the other end of the phone.)

Joff said at June 26th, 2007 at 10:12am

Nice bit of Google Maps mashing-up going on:

http://news.sky.com/skynews/fixed_article/0,,30100-1272280,00.html

Leave a comment

This website's Gravatar enabled (that's the pictures on the right)

To prove you're human, type the two words below into the box provided.